Murder & manslaughter lawyer in Toronto
These are the most serious charges in the Criminal Code, and the stakes could not be higher. The investigation will already be extensive by the time you learn you are a suspect. Experienced counsel from the earliest possible moment is not a precaution here — it is essential.
Speak to a lawyer before you speak to anyone else.
Calls answered 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. Free initial consultation. Confidentiality guaranteed.
First and second degree murder
Murder carries a mandatory sentence of life imprisonment in Canada; there is no discretion on that point. The first and second degree distinction does not change that mandatory life sentence — it changes the period before parole eligibility. First degree requires planning and deliberation, or arises from certain specific circumstances the law treats as equally grave, and carries 25 years before parole eligibility. Second degree carries a period set by the sentencing judge, generally between 10 and 25 years. Whether a killing was planned and deliberate, or whether it falls instead to second degree or to manslaughter, is very often the entire case.
Manslaughter
Manslaughter is a culpable homicide that falls short of murder — a death caused by an unlawful act, without the intent to kill or to cause bodily harm known to be likely to cause death that murder requires. It can arise where an assault or other unlawful act unexpectedly results in death, or in narrow circumstances where what would otherwise be murder is reduced because of a recognised partial defence. Unlike murder, manslaughter carries no mandatory minimum for a first offence in most circumstances, which makes the distinction between the two charges enormously consequential.
Criminal negligence causing death
This is a separate route to liability, based not on intent but on conduct that shows a marked and substantial departure from the standard of care a reasonable person would have observed — a considerably higher bar than ordinary negligence. Workplace deaths, serious driving cases, and cases involving a duty of care toward another person are the contexts where this charge most often arises, and the gap between a tragic accident and genuinely criminal conduct is exactly what needs to be tested.
Defences and reductions
Self-defence, where it applies, is a complete defence resulting in an acquittal, not a reduction. Causation is frequently a live issue — whether the accused's act actually caused the death, or whether something else intervened, has to be proven, not assumed. The Crown's ability to prove the specific mental state required for murder, as opposed to manslaughter, is very often the real fight in a case that looks, on its face, like a murder charge. The law around intoxication as it relates to violent offences has changed significantly in recent years and is genuinely complex; if it may be relevant to your case, it needs to be discussed with a lawyer directly rather than assumed one way or the other.
Where these cases are defended
- Causation. Whether the act actually caused the death, particularly where medical treatment, a pre-existing condition, or another person's conduct may have intervened.
- The mental element. Proving what someone actually intended, as opposed to what happened, is the difference between murder and manslaughter in a great many cases.
- Forensic and pathology evidence. Time and cause of death, and whether the physical evidence actually supports the Crown's account of events.
- Witness reliability. These cases are often built on statements taken under enormous stress, and inconsistencies matter.
- Charter issues. These are the most resource-intensive investigations the police conduct, and how statements, searches, and wiretaps were obtained is scrutinized closely.
What to do now
- Say nothing to the police without a lawyer present. This matters in every case, but here more than anywhere — you have the right to silence and the right to counsel, and you should exercise both before answering any question.
- Do not discuss the allegation with anyone other than your lawyer, including family, in any communication that could later be produced.
- Call a lawyer immediately, even if you have only been told you are a person of interest and have not yet been charged. What happens in the hours after an incident often shapes the entire case.
Common questions
Will I get bail on a murder charge?
Bail on a murder charge is far from automatic, and the onus can shift to the accused to show why detention isn't justified rather than the Crown having to justify detention. It is a serious, involved hearing, not a formality, and it needs to be prepared for carefully.
What's the actual difference between murder and manslaughter?
Murder requires an intent to kill, or to cause bodily harm known to be likely to cause death. Manslaughter is a death caused by an unlawful act without that specific intent. The two carry very different consequences, which is exactly why the Crown's ability to prove intent is so often the central issue.
Can self-defence apply to a murder or manslaughter charge?
Yes. Where self-defence applies and is accepted, it results in a full acquittal rather than a lesser charge or sentence. Whether it applies depends closely on the specific facts, including what was reasonably believed and how the response compared to the threat.
Is there parole for a life sentence?
Yes, parole eligibility is built into a life sentence for murder — 25 years for first degree, and a period generally between 10 and 25 years set by the sentencing judge for second degree. Eligibility for parole is not the same as release; it only opens the possibility of applying.
What is criminal negligence causing death, and how is it different from manslaughter?
It is a separate charge based on conduct that shows a marked and substantial departure from the standard of care a reasonable person would observe, rather than on an unlawful act. It most often arises in workplace, driving, or duty-of-care contexts, and the standard is deliberately a demanding one.
Talk to us about your case
Every Defence LLP has defended criminal charges across Ontario since 2006. Our office is at 920 Yonge Street, Suite 602, Toronto. The first consultation is free and the phone is answered around the clock.